During these productions, they incorporated silent auctions into the events as more robust ways of fundraising. The four productions of Annie together, along with other fundraising efforts, raised over $85,000. In 2005, the sisters switched the show from the standard Annie to the equally renowned musical Grease, which would be performed twice: once in 2005 and again in 2006. With these shows also came the introduction of the Kids Acting Against Cancer Producers’ Reception. This event would precede the performance and feature drinks and hors d’oeuvres in addition to the silent auction. Consequently, Kids Acting Against Cancer began embracing its one-night-only fundraising model, which would continue developing in the subsequent years.

As a form of outreach in 2005, KAAC volunteers began distributing KAACpacks (backpacks filled with fun goodies) to children undergoing cancer treatment at Norton Children’s Hospital. Additionally in 2005, Kids Acting Against Cancer reached out to the national organization of Gilda’s Club, which had been planning to open a branch in Louisville, and officially pledged to sponsor the Game Room at Gilda’s Club Louisville with a $100,000 donation. The first major step toward this goal was the 2007 production of the United States premiere of A Little Princess – the first show to be produced in The Kentucky Center for the Performing Arts by Kids Acting Against Cancer. Following that show, Jennifer Cobb, recipient of The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society Woman of the Year Award, chose Kids Acting Against Cancer as her beneficiary and donated $30,000 to the nonprofit.

Kids Acting Against Cancer continued to perform various musicals as fundraising events – wherein the focus was on fundraising, not necessarily on the quality of theatre itself – from 2007 through 2012, including Into the Woods, The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, High School Musical and Cinderella. Cinderella, which was performed in the Bomhard Theatre of The Kentucky Center for the Arts, received significant media attention and yielded sufficient funds in ticket sales and donations to pay off the $100,000 pledge to Gilda’s Club Louisville.

In October 2012, after watching a production of Dracula at Actors Theatre Louisville, Whitten Montgomery and Remy Sisk, who had grown from just an actor and volunteer into a leader in the company, began to toy with the idea of performing a straight play instead of the usual expensive musical. Thus, in January of 2013, Kids Acting Against Cancer chose to stage the murder mystery And Then There Were None in the more intimate MeX Theater of The Kentucky Center. And as the show was cheaper to produce, there was room to run the show over multiple nights as opposed to the standard one-night-only. Many were trepidatious of the organization’s change; however, fears were assuaged as the show was a success with the group’s following and marked KAAC’s first sold-out show. With lower expenses than ever, And Then There Were None proved to be the most successful show to date in quality and in fundraising, leading the team to begin focusing just as equally on artistic integrity as on fundraising.

KAAC continued to develop its emerging new brand while producing small-scale straight shows for the rest of 2013. With renewed confidence, the organization returned to its musical roots in January 2014 with the regional premiere of the Tony Award-winning musical Spring Awakening. The show brought the organization more public attention than ever, which resulted in a sold-out six show run. Reception and profits were both overwhelmingly positive, which prompted the group to perform another edgy musical, RENT, in June 2014. The show was similarly successful and was performed experimentally in the gritty venue of The Tim Faulkner Gallery. Working with Charlie Meredith, who had become more involved in organization leadership during pre-production for Spring Awakening, KAAC embraced its burgeoning identity as a theatre company that focuses on modern, pop/rock-oriented musicals and planned its first official “season.”

KAAC continued to develop its emerging new brand while producing small-scale straight shows for the rest of 2013. With renewed confidence, the organization returned to its musical roots in January 2014 with the regional premiere of the Tony Award-winning musical Spring Awakening. The show brought the organization more public attention than ever, which resulted in a sold-out six show run. Reception and profits were both overwhelmingly positive, which prompted the group to perform another edgy musical, RENT, in June 2014. The show was similarly successful and was performed experimentally in the gritty venue of The Tim Faulkner Gallery. Working with Charlie Meredith, who had become more involved in organization leadership during pre-production for Spring Awakening, KAAC embraced its burgeoning identity as a theatre company that focuses on modern, pop/rock-oriented musicals and planned its first official “season.”

Together, Whitten, Remy and Charlie worked with a local designer to develop a new logo and name – in the end, the simplest seemed to make the most sense: they weren’t “Kids” anymore, but they were still “Acting Against Cancer.” With a new brand, Acting Against Cancer dove into its season of The Rocky Horror Show, Next to Normal and The Real Inspector Hound while working more closely with Norton Children’s Hospital and its expressive art therapy program in particular. Rocky Horror would in fact prove to be the first in a string of yearly Halloween-time productions of the show by the company, now an annual tradition in partnership with PLAY Louisville.